Telephone triage for chest pain: the patient who wants a home visit
You are the duty GP at a practice at 16:40. Mrs Elaine Barker, 45, phones saying she has had central chest pain for 30 minutes. It is 'heavy', radiates to her left arm, and is associated with sweating and nausea. She has no previous cardiac history. She takes the combined oral contraceptive pill, smokes 10 cigarettes/day, and her BMI is 27. Her father had a myocardial infarction at 60. She is at home alone with her 7-year-old daughter and says she cannot drive to the surgery. She asks for a home visit because 'it's probably just stress' and she does not want to trouble the ambulance service. The practice is fully booked; the practice nurse could do an ECG at 17:10, and the next GP appointment is 17:30. The patient becomes tearful and says she will wait for a home visit.
1. What is the most appropriate immediate action, and why? Include the differential and immediate treatment.
Read the worked answer
Treat this as a possible acute coronary syndrome until proven otherwise. She has central heavy chest pain radiating to the left arm with sweating and nausea, plus smoking, combined oral contraceptive use and a family history. The immediate action is to call an emergency ambulance now, not arrange a home visit or wait for the practice nurse's ECG. The ambulance can provide monitoring, aspirin, nitrates and defibrillation if needed, and can take her to a centre with angiography. I would keep her on the phone, advise her to unlock the door, sit down and not exert herself, and ask about aspirin allergy or recent bleeding before advising 300 mg aspirin to chew. I would also consider other causes - aortic dissection, pulmonary embolism, musculoskeletal pain, anxiety - but none should delay ambulance activation. The key reasoning is that time-critical treatment cannot be provided in a GP surgery or at home.
2. How would you communicate with a patient who insists on waiting for a home visit?
Read the worked answer
I would validate her concern rather than argue: 'I understand you don't want to make a fuss, and you're worried about your daughter.' Then be clear: 'This pain has features that can be a heart attack, and I can't safely assess that over the phone or wait for a home visit. The ambulance can check your heart at home and bring treatment if needed.' I would offer practical help: ask if a neighbour can stay with her daughter or bring her to the door, and reassure her that the crew will not judge her. I would avoid overpromising ('it's probably nothing') and avoid frightening language. If she continued to refuse, I would document the advice and consider whether she has capacity, involve a colleague or emergency services, and not simply accept the delay.
3. What would you document and hand over?
Read the worked answer
I would document the time of the call, the exact symptoms and radiation, risk factors, the advice given, the ambulance request and time, aspirin dose and consent, and that she was advised not to drive. I would record her concerns about her daughter and who was contacted for childcare. I would hand over to the ambulance crew using SBAR and inform the practice of the incident. Documentation should also note that a home visit was not arranged and why, because this is a high-risk decision. If she declined, I would record her capacity and the safety advice given.