The Man Who Needs to Get to the Bank
Mr. Halvorsen, 82, has moderate Alzheimer's disease and has lived on your hall for two years. It is 7:20 a.m. and he is scheduled for his twice-weekly shower before breakfast trays arrive at 7:45. He is pacing the hallway in his pajamas, picking at his sleeve, and repeating, "I have to get to the bank - Ruth is waiting for me in the car." Ruth, his wife of 51 years, died four years ago. When you bring the shower chair toward him he steps back, raises his voice, and says, "Don't you touch me." His hair and underarms are soiled, and he has a reddened area under his left breast that the nurse is watching. You are the only aide on the hall for the next ten minutes.
1. What do you say and do in the first two minutes? Explain the reasoning behind each choice.
Read the worked answer
Do not correct him and do not argue. Telling him Ruth is dead forces him to grieve fresh news he cannot hold onto, and it usually escalates agitation. Instead use validation plus redirection: stand in front of him at eye level, arms relaxed, and say something like, "You have always taken care of business, Mr. Halvorsen. Ruth is counting on you." Then give one concrete, low-demand task that fits his story: "Help me fold these two towels while I get your things ready."
Remove the trigger. The shower chair itself started the escalation, so move it out of sight and out of reach before you continue. Keep your voice low and slow, one instruction at a time - multi-step directions fail in moderate dementia.
Screen for an unmet physical need in the same breath: pain, a full bladder, hunger, an uncomfortable room temperature, or too much hallway noise can all read as agitation. Ask simply if he needs the bathroom, and check whether he is favoring his left side.
Do not touch him without warning. Announce each contact before you make it. Physical force is never an option.
2. Ten minutes later he is still refusing and the trays have arrived. What do you do about the shower, and what do you report and document?
Read the worked answer
Honor the refusal. A resident with dementia still holds the right to refuse a non-emergency bath; a shower is not an emergency. Physically forcing him would be battery and would be reportable as abuse, and it would also make every future bath harder.
Reschedule, don't cancel. Bathing can happen later in the day. Note the pattern - he became agitated the moment the shower chair appeared, at a time of morning when he is rushed and the hall is busy. A later, unhurried, one-on-one attempt is far more likely to succeed.
Meet the minimum need now without a bath: a partial wash at the sink of face, hands, underarms, and under the breasts, if he tolerates it, and clean pajamas.
Report to the nurse: the refusal, the escalation, and specifically the reddened area under the left breast, which needs a skin assessment whether or not he bathes.
Document objectively: what care was offered, what he said, what care was actually given, and who was notified. Avoid labels like "combative" - describe behavior.
3. That afternoon, rested and calm, he accepts a bed bath. What made the difference, and what do you hand off to the next shift?
Read the worked answer
What made the difference was timing and approach rather than persuasion: he was rested, the hall was quiet, no shower chair was in view, one caregiver gave one direction at a time, and the task was framed as something he could accept rather than something done to him.
Hand off the pattern, not just the outcome. Tell the next shift:
- He escalates when he sees the shower chair, especially early morning.
- He does better later in the day with a bed bath or sink wash and a step-by-step approach.
- Do not argue about Ruth or the bank; validate and redirect.
- The skin fold under the left breast needs to be checked and reported each shift.
- Refusals have been occurring; if this becomes a multi-day pattern, the nurse should take it to the care plan team to rework the bathing schedule and method.
This is the difference between reporting an event and solving a problem - the next shift needs the pattern so the same standoff does not repeat tomorrow.