Four Refusals and a Daughter in the Doorway
Mrs. Alvarado, 68, is on your rehab hall three weeks after surgical repair of a hip fracture. She is alert, oriented, and makes her own decisions. Her care plan calls for a shower three times weekly, and her hip incision is to be kept dry until the surgeon clears her. She has refused her shower four mornings in a row, saying, "I wash at the sink, I am not getting into that chair." When you help her dress you notice her hair is unwashed and a reddened, moist area in the skin fold under her right breast. At 10:00 her daughter arrives and says to you, "She's always been fussy about being clean - just tell her she has no choice and get it done. And while you're at it, what did the doctor say about her incision yesterday?"
1. How do you answer the daughter - on both the shower and the doctor's report?
Read the worked answer
The incision question first: you do not answer it. Health information belongs to Mrs. Alvarado, who is alert and oriented and has not authorized you to share it, and a CNA does not interpret physician findings even with permission. Say warmly, "I'm not able to discuss her medical information - let me get the nurse, who can talk with you." Then actually do it, or take the daughter to the nurse. Do not confirm or deny anything, including "it looked fine."
The shower demand: acknowledge the concern without agreeing to it. "It's clear how much you care about her. She's alert and makes her own decisions, and I can't force her into the shower - nobody here can." Offer a useful role: ask what soap and shampoo she prefers at home, what time of day she used to bathe, whether she wants her daughter present or out of the room.
Do not let the daughter become the decision-maker just because she is persistent. A capable resident outranks a visiting family member on personal care decisions.
2. How do you work with Mrs. Alvarado herself, and what do you report?
Read the worked answer
Find the barrier before pushing the solution. Four refusals is a message. Ask open questions - is she afraid of falling during the chair transfer, is the seat cold or the room drafty, does the spray hurt her hip, does she want privacy, does she dislike the aide or the time? "I'm not getting into that chair" points hard at fear of falling or of the incision getting wet.
Offer real options, not one take-it-or-leave-it bath: a shower chair with a towel draped across the seat and a warm room; a hand-held spray used away from the hip; a shampoo over the sink plus a basin wash; a different time of day; a different aide. Ask the nurse to clarify the "keep dry" order - whether the dressing is waterproof and whether the surgeon has lifted the restriction.
Report: the four refusals, the unwashed hair, and especially the reddened, moist skin fold under the right breast, which needs a nurse's skin assessment.
Document what you did give, not only what she refused.
3. At what point does this stop being a preference and become a problem the team must solve? How do you document it?
Read the worked answer
It becomes a team problem when the refusals create a risk you cannot manage alone. Signs here: four consecutive refusals, skin breakdown beginning in the breast fold, and uncertainty about whether the incision is actually protected during sink washing. Add a possible mood component - withdrawal from a formerly fastidious woman can signal depression, not stubbornness.
Escalate to the nurse, who can assess skin and incision, revise the care plan, bring in OT for the transfer fear, and consider a social work or mood screen. Refusal that persists despite a revised approach belongs at an interdisciplinary care plan meeting.
Document objectively, per facility policy: the date and time, what care was offered, her exact words ("I am not getting into that chair"), what care was actually provided, the skin observation in plain description without diagnosis, and the name of the nurse notified. Never write "noncompliant" or "difficult" - describe behavior.
Never force care, and never chart a shower you did not give.