Debt Triage for a Family with a Payday Loan
A couple with two children, ages 6 and 9, has take-home pay of $3,450 per month. Fixed expenses are rent $1,150, utilities $260, car payment $310 at 14.9% APR with three years left, insurance $180, and childcare $420. They have $5,900 in credit-card debt across two cards: Card A has a $3,200 balance at 22.99% APR with a $96 minimum; Card B has a $2,700 balance at 27.99% APR with an $81 minimum. They also owe $700 on a payday loan due in nine days with a $105 finance charge, and they have $210 in checking. The car needs $480 in brake work; they have been using the payday loan to cover gaps. They contribute nothing to savings and expect a $1,200 tax refund in 10 weeks. They ask whether to consolidate with a home-equity loan at 8.5% APR with $900 closing costs or use a debt snowball.
1. Construct a prioritized 60-day cash-flow plan. Address the payday loan, the brake repair, food and transportation, and the tax refund. Show the arithmetic and identify the first three actions.
Read the worked answer
Monthly fixed costs total $2,320, leaving $1,130 before food, gas, and debt. Credit-card minimums total $177, leaving about $953. With a bare-bones food/gas estimate of $600, only about $353 remains-before the $700 payday loan and $480 brakes. The gap is real, so the first action is not “snowball” but crisis triage: (1) contact the payday lender before the due date, ask for a written repayment plan, and stop rolling the loan; (2) get two written brake estimates and prioritize safety, using $210 checking plus $270 from a planned small sale or employer advance, not another payday loan; (3) call the credit-card issuers to request due-date changes and hardship options. For 60 days, pause extra debt payments, keep minimums current, and use the $1,200 refund first to clear the payday balance and then the brakes. Food and housing are protected first; a home-equity consolidation with $900 closing costs is not viable now because it adds debt and risks the home. After the payday loan is gone, redirect the $105-plus payment to Card B.
2. Compare avalanche, snowball, and home-equity consolidation for this family. Recommend one approach and justify it with numbers and risk.
Read the worked answer
Avalanche targets Card B first because 27.99% is the highest rate; snowball also targets Card B first because it is the smaller balance. The methods coincide here, so the “behavioral” snowball advantage costs nothing. If they pay $200 extra monthly after clearing the payday loan, avalanche/snowball saves more interest than spreading payments evenly. Consolidation at 8.5% looks cheaper, but the $900 closing cost is about 15% of the $5,900 balance; if they keep the same payment, the break-even period is long, and the home becomes collateral. Given irregular cash flow and a recent payday loan, risking the home is inappropriate. I would recommend the snowball/avalanche hybrid: pay minimums, attack Card B with every extra dollar, then Card A, while building a $500 starter emergency fund. The numerical difference between avalanche and snowball is zero in this case; the risk difference between unsecured cards and a home-equity loan is substantial. Revisit consolidation only after six months of on-time payments and a funded emergency reserve.
3. Identify the predatory features of the payday loan and two consumer protections or behavioral strategies the family should use.
Read the worked answer
The $105 finance charge on $700 for nine days is an annualized cost far above typical credit-card rates-roughly 600% APR-and the balloon due date is designed to coincide with insufficient cash, encouraging rollover. The family’s pattern of using new payday loans to cover old gaps is the classic debt trap. Protections and strategies: first, insist on a written loan disclosure showing the finance charge and APR, and use the lender’s repayment-plan option if state law requires one; second, contact a nonprofit credit-counseling agency or a community action agency for a debt-management plan rather than a for-profit “consolidation” offer. Behaviorally, they should automate a small transfer to savings on payday, use a cash envelope for food/gas, and impose a 24-hour rule before any new borrowing. They should also request a free credit report to check for errors and ask the card issuers about hardship programs. The key judgment is to stop the borrowing cycle before optimizing interest rates.