Night Cargo Pressure and a Below-Minima Visual Approach
At 0210 local, a night cargo turboprop is at Iloilo (RPVI) preparing for a 45-minute flight to Cebu (RPVM). The captain has been on duty 13.5 hours and tells the dispatcher he has been awake since 0600 the previous day. Cebu is reporting wind calm, visibility 1,200 m in mist, vertical visibility 200 ft, and the ILS is unserviceable; the only approach is a VOR circling procedure with company minima of 1,000 ft ceiling and 2,400 m visibility. The captain says, "I've done this a hundred times; we'll take a visual approach and be on the ground before the fog thickens." The first officer, on his second line check, says nothing. The dispatcher also hears the captain yawn and repeat a clearance. Company policy requires an alternate when destination weather is at or below minima; Cebu's alternate, Bohol, is 25 minutes away and forecast clear. Fuel is sufficient.
1. Identify the human factors and operational/regulatory issues in this situation.
Read the worked answer
The captain shows significant fatigue risk: 13.5 hours on duty and awake since 0600 the previous day means roughly 20 hours awake at 0210. The yawning and repeated clearance are additional warning signs. Commercial pressure is present because this is a night cargo flight, and the captain's statement "I've done this a hundred times" is an experience-based justification rather than a weather assessment.
The first officer's silence is a CRM concern: a new first officer on a line check may not feel able to challenge the captain. The dispatcher also faces an authority gradient and must be assertive.
Operationally, Cebu is below company minima: visibility 1,200 m is less than 2,400 m, and vertical visibility 200 ft is below the 1,000 ft ceiling requirement. The ILS is unserviceable, so the only approach is a circling procedure. A visual approach cannot be conducted when the required visual reference is not available. The alternate at Bohol does not cure a destination that is below minima at the planned arrival; it only provides a diversion option.
2. What should the dispatcher say and do?
Read the worked answer
The dispatcher should state the facts concisely: "Cebu is below company minima for the only available approach; I cannot release a visual approach." Then offer options: delay at Iloilo until the weather improves or a trend forecast supports dispatch, divert to Bohol, or cancel. If the captain insists, the dispatcher should escalate to the duty manager or chief pilot rather than argue indefinitely. The dispatcher should not sign or transmit a release that implies the approach is acceptable.
Use closed-loop communication with both crew members: ask the first officer to confirm the weather and the plan, which gives him a legitimate opening to speak. Raise the fatigue concern directly and ask whether the captain is fit to continue. Document the weather, the captain's request, the options offered, and the escalation. A confidential fatigue or safety report should follow if the captain continues to press.
3. If the flight departs and the captain requests a visual approach at Cebu, what should ATS and the dispatcher do?
Read the worked answer
ATS should provide the current weather and should not issue a visual approach clearance if the reported conditions do not permit one. The crew remains responsible for minima, but the controller should state the visibility and vertical visibility and offer the circling approach or holding. If the aircraft commences an approach, it must not continue below minima without the required visual reference; a missed approach and diversion to Bohol would be expected.
The dispatcher should pass updated Cebu and Bohol weather, confirm the alternate fuel and diversion plan, and be ready to coordinate priority handling. If the crew declares an emergency, the dispatcher should obtain the nature of the emergency, fuel endurance and souls on board, and notify the response services. After landing, the event should be documented and reviewed, with particular attention to fatigue, dispatch pressure and the first officer's ability to challenge.