A Producing Branch Manager, an Unapproved Oil-and-Gas Program, and an Unregistered Order-Taker
Prairie branch has 11 registered reps and a branch manager, Carla Jensen, who personally generates 55% of branch revenue. Compliance's last on-site inspection of the branch is 14 months overdue. During an email review, compliance flags rep Marcus Yi soliciting clients to buy interests in 'Prairie Wind Holdings,' an oil-and-gas DPP that is not on the firm's approved product list. Yi says the program is 'personal, outside the firm.' A sales assistant in the branch, who holds no registrations, has been taking DPP order tickets by phone when Jensen travels and initialing them 'CJ per instruction.' Two client emails in the same review say 'Marcus promised the 7% return was guaranteed.' Jensen, asked about all of this, says he 'keeps an eye on Yi' and that the branch inspection is an administrative item.
1. Identify the supervisory failures in this branch and explain why the reporting lines make them worse.
Read the worked answer
There are at least four separate failures, and the branching structure explains why they survived.
- No on-site inspection. Offices of supervisory jurisdiction must be inspected at least annually, and other branch offices on a periodic schedule. Fourteen months is outside the cycle; calling the inspection 'administrative' is itself a supervisory failure because the inspection is the control that catches everything else on this list.
- Producing manager as sole supervisor. Jensen writes 55% of branch revenue and reviews his own branch. Compensation and supervision are in direct conflict; the WSPs should have a different principal reviewing his and his branch's activity.
- Unregistered order-taking. An unregistered assistant accepting DPP order tickets is performing a registered function. Initialing tickets 'CJ per instruction' is not delegation - it is a record that misrepresents who took the order.
- Unreviewed outside activity. Yi's program never reached a principal for approval; 'personal, outside the firm' is not a category that exists for a registered rep selling securities to firm clients.
The common root cause is that no independent principal has looked at this branch's emails, tickets, and outside-activity logs at the same time. Each item was individually survivable; together they show the system was not operating.
2. How should the firm handle Marcus Yi's Prairie Wind Holdings activity? Address the rule categories and the consequences if clients were sold.
Read the worked answer
Treat it as potential selling away until proven otherwise.
- Outside business activity: prior written notice and firm approval are required before a registered person may be employed by or compensated by another entity. Yi has no approval.
- Private securities transactions: if Prairie Wind interests are securities and Yi solicited firm clients or received transaction-based compensation, the firm needed written notice and either approval-with-recording or a determination that he would not participate. Neither happened. Even an approved private transaction goes on the firm's books.
- Potential unregistered broker-dealer activity on the issuer's side, and potential use of firm client lists and firm time.
- The 'guaranteed 7%' claim is a separate problem: an unapproved, misleading projection communicated to clients, which is the kind of statement that turns a supervisory case into a fraud case.
Consequences if clients were sold: immediate investigation to identify every affected client and every dollar; remediation decisions for clients; the rep's continued association evaluated (including whether a permitted-to-resign or termination event must be reported and the Form U5 filed); reporting to FINRA as required; and a written supervisory plan for the branch. Jensen's 'I keep an eye on him' is not a supervisory system and should be documented as such in the file.
3. Draft the corrective action plan. Which items must happen immediately, and which can be scheduled?
Read the worked answer
Immediate (before the next business day):
- Suspend Yi's DPP-related activity and client contact on Prairie Wind pending the investigation; preserve emails and texts.
- Remove the unregistered assistant from any order-taking or customer-contact role involving securities; correct the ticket-initial practice and identify all tickets she handled.
- Assign a principal other than Jensen to review Jensen's and Yi's transactions prospectively - a producing manager cannot be the sole reviewer of his own revenue.
Within 30 days:
- Complete the overdue on-site inspection with a written report, including ticket samples, correspondence review, and outside-activity verification.
- Reconcile the outside-activity log against BrokerCheck, correspondence, and client records branch-wide.
- Interview the affected clients; determine whether any client was sold Prairie Wind and whether suitability or misrepresentation issues exist.
- Update WSPs: annual OSJ inspection calendar with an escalation owner, a pre-approval gate for DPP tickets, and a rule that unregistered staff may not accept orders.
Ongoing:
- Heightened supervision of the branch and of Jensen's supervisory role, with quarterly reporting to senior management until the inspection cycle is current and clean.
The exam-tested judgment is the separation: containment first (stop the conduct, protect clients), then investigation, then structural fix. A plan that starts with 'retrain the branch' has the order wrong.