Employee Theft Investigation
You are the rooms division manager at a 250-room hotel. Over the past month, the hotel has experienced a series of thefts from guest rooms, primarily small electronics and cash. The losses total approximately $3,000. You have narrowed down the suspects to three room attendants who have access to the master keys. All three have been with the hotel for over a year and have clean records. The hotel has a strict policy against theft, and termination is the standard consequence. However, you lack concrete evidence. You have surveillance footage showing one of the attendants, Maria, entering a room at a time when she was not assigned to that room. The other two, John and Lisa, have no such footage. The general manager wants to involve the police, but you are concerned about the hotel's reputation and the possibility of a wrongful accusation. You also have a tight budget and cannot afford to increase security. The HR director suggests conducting interviews with all three. Your task is to determine the best course of action.
1. How would you conduct the investigation to balance the need to resolve the thefts with protecting employee rights?
Read the worked answer
First, I would review all available evidence: the surveillance footage, key card access logs, and any other records. The footage of Maria entering an unassigned room is suspicious but not conclusive; she might have had a legitimate reason (e.g., delivering supplies, covering for someone). I would check the key card logs to see if her key was used in other unassigned rooms. I would also interview the other attendants to see if they noticed anything unusual. Before interviewing the suspects, I would consult with HR and legal to ensure the process is fair and consistent with policy. I would conduct separate interviews with each attendant, starting with the ones with no evidence, to gather information without accusing. For Maria, I would ask about the specific instance and give her a chance to explain. I would document everything. If no admission or further evidence emerges, I might need to increase monitoring (e.g., random bag checks, which should be in policy) or install cameras in hallways (but budget constraints). I would also consider that the thefts might be by someone else, like a guest or another staff member. I would not terminate without solid evidence. If Maria's explanation is unsatisfactory, I might reassign her to a different shift or area while continuing the investigation. The goal is to protect the hotel and employees. I would also communicate with the GM about the risks of involving police prematurely.
2. What would you do if Maria admits to the thefts during the interview?
Read the worked answer
If Maria admits, I would first ensure the interview is documented and witnessed by HR. I would ask her to write a statement. Then, I would follow the hotel's disciplinary policy, which likely includes termination and possibly restitution. I would also involve the police if the hotel policy requires it, but I would consider the GM's stance. Since the thefts total $3,000, it might be a felony depending on local laws. I would consult with legal. I would also check if any stolen items can be recovered. I would terminate Maria for cause, ensuring all paperwork is complete. I would then communicate to the rest of the staff that the matter has been resolved, without disclosing details, to maintain morale. I would also review security procedures to prevent future incidents, such as key control audits and increased supervision. Finally, I would offer support to the other attendants who were under suspicion, to rebuild trust.