The Underperforming F&B Outlet: Reinvent, Reposition, or Close
Your 160-room hotel has a 90-seat restaurant that lost $240,000 last year on revenue of $1.1 million. Food cost is 34%, labor is 41% of revenue, and covers average 48 at dinner and 22 at lunch. The space is prime lobby frontage. A local operator has offered to lease the space for $180,000 per year plus a percentage of sales, and would keep the hotel's guests served. Guests rate the restaurant 3.6 out of 5, and the concierge reports that guests increasingly ask for local recommendations. Ownership wants a recommendation within 30 days and is nervous about losing an amenity.
1. Evaluate whether to keep operating, reposition, or lease the space, showing the numbers behind your recommendation.
Read the worked answer
Start with the loss structure. Revenue is $1.1 million, food cost is 34% or $374,000, and labor is 41% or $451,000. Those two lines alone total $825,000, leaving $275,000 before rent, utilities, and other costs, yet the outlet lost $240,000, so fixed and overhead costs are consuming the margin. The outlet is not marginally unprofitable; it is structurally unprofitable at current volume.
Leasing changes the math sharply. The lease yields $180,000 plus a sales percentage, turning a $240,000 loss into a positive contribution, a swing of at least $420,000 before any percentage. The amenity concern is real but manageable: the lease can require the operator to honor guest charge-back, keep breakfast service, and maintain quality standards. Repositioning in-house would require capital, a new concept, and time, with no guarantee of fixing a 41% labor ratio. My recommendation would be to negotiate the lease with protective conditions, unless a credible repositioning plan shows a path to positive contribution within 12 months. The numbers favor the lease; the judgement is in the conditions.
2. What conditions would you insist on in the lease to protect the guest experience?
Read the worked answer
The lease must protect the amenity the hotel is selling. I would require defined operating hours covering breakfast and dinner, a minimum quality standard with guest-satisfaction thresholds, and the right to audit. I would require the operator to accept room charge-back so guests can bill to their room, and to honor loyalty program benefits. I would set a service-level agreement with remedies, including termination rights if standards are missed for a defined period.
I would also protect the hotel's brand. The operator should not be permitted to use signage that implies the hotel operates the outlet, and the hotel should approve the concept and any rebranding. I would negotiate the percentage rent with a floor and a reporting obligation, and require the operator to carry insurance naming the hotel. Finally, I would build a transition plan so current staff have redeployment or interview priority, because a closure without that damages morale and the local labor reputation. The conditions are where the real negotiation happens; the headline rent is only the starting point.
3. Staff are rumored to be worried about their jobs. How would you communicate, and when?
Read the worked answer
Rumors damage trust faster than bad news. I would communicate before the 30-day decision is final, but only with what is actually known: that the outlet is being reviewed, that no decision has been made, and that staff will hear from me directly before anything is announced externally. I would hold short team meetings with the restaurant staff and the wider hotel team, and I would avoid promising outcomes I cannot guarantee.
Once a decision is made, I would communicate within 24 hours, in person, with clear timelines and concrete support: redeployment options, interview priority with the operator, severance where applicable, and named contacts. I would also brief the concierge and front desk so they can answer guest questions consistently. The judgement is to be early with uncertainty and immediate with decisions, because silence fills with the worst assumption and drives the best staff to leave before you need them.