Noise Complaint, White Powder and Six Phone Cameras
At 23:40 on a Saturday, you are a uniformed constable on solo foot patrol in a public housing estate in Sham Shui Po. A resident in flat 1408 complains about loud music from flat 1410. At the door, a 15-year-old boy opens, smelling of alcohol. The music is loud. On the coffee table in plain view are a small clear plastic bag containing white powder and a rolled-up HK$100 note. Two other youths, aged 16 and 17, are sitting inside. Six neighbours are filming in the corridor; one shouts, 'Police brutality,' although no force has been used. Your radio reports that backup is eight minutes away. The boy says the powder is 'baking soda' and begs you not to call his parents. The flat door is open; the youths are not blocking you. You have not searched anyone.
1. What should you do in the first five minutes? Identify the legal powers, the limits on those powers, and the order of priority.
Read the worked answer
Priority order: (1) officer and public safety; (2) prevent disposal of evidence and preserve the scene; (3) protect the minors' welfare; (4) manage the crowd. Practically: call up the radio for priority backup, note the time, ask the youths to stand apart and keep their hands visible, and do not enter or search the flat unless necessary. The bag and rolled note are in plain view from a place you are lawfully standing; note their location and prevent anyone from touching them. Put on gloves before handling. Do not accept the 'baking soda' explanation at face value; a field test may assist but is not conclusive. You may arrest without warrant if you have reasonable suspicion of an arrestable offence, including possession of a dangerous drug under the Dangerous Drugs Ordinance, and you may seize evidence incident to arrest or in plain view. Limits: no general search of the flat or phones without consent, warrant or a lawful arrest power; no strip search; no force beyond what is necessary. The noise issue is secondary; ask for the music to be turned down, but do not let that distract from the suspected drugs. Record everything and maintain the chain of evidence.
2. How do you handle the six neighbours who are filming and the shouted allegation of 'police brutality'?
Read the worked answer
Stay calm and professional; being filmed in a common corridor is not itself an offence, and there is no power to seize or delete phones simply because you are being recorded. Activate your body-worn camera if issued and announce clearly what you are doing. Briefly explain that you are dealing with a report and ask people to step back beyond a safe distance; do not give details about the minors or the suspected drugs. Do not argue with the person shouting. Record the time, what was said, and any footage that might later be relevant. Treat the allegation as a complaint: note it and report it through the proper channel. If someone physically obstructs you or interferes with evidence, warn clearly and use the minimum lawful force or arrest only if an offence is committed. Afterward, make a contemporaneous note; do not try to 'win' the crowd on the spot.
3. What are your obligations towards the 15-year-old and the other two minors?
Read the worked answer
The 15-year-old is a juvenile. If you arrest him, inform him of the reason and caution him in words he understands. Notify a parent or guardian of the arrest and whereabouts as soon as practicable; do not use 'I will call your parents' as a threat to extract a statement. A parent, guardian or appropriate adult should be present for any interview, and the juvenile should not be interviewed alone. Consider welfare: he smells of alcohol, so assess whether he needs medical attention and whether he is at risk. The 16- and 17-year-olds are also minors; separate them, take their details, and decide whether they are witnesses, suspects or persons at risk. Use the least intrusive option consistent with the evidence; arrest is not automatic. If the case is not continued, release on bail or other lawful conditions and record the decision.