The 90-second appeal with a consent gap
Northside Food Network has five days to finish a 90-second year-end appeal video. Four volunteers shot footage on two phones: one records 4K vertical at 60 fps, the other 1080 horizontal at 30 fps. Interview audio was captured with one borrowed lapel mic and has a constant refrigerator hum; the interview room has a bright window behind the speaker. The subject, Maria, signed a release limited to “internal reporting and grant applications.” The communications director now wants to run the video as a paid Meta ad, embed it on the donation page, and send it to a local TV station. The volunteer editor has ten hours and no captioning budget. The draft includes a music track a volunteer found online and a shot of a child’s face in the food line. The donation page accepts one-time gifts only. What should the team do?
1. What must happen before this video can be distributed publicly and as a paid ad?
Read the worked answer
Distribution must stop until consent and rights are resolved. Maria’s release covers internal reporting and grant applications, not public marketing, paid advertising, or broadcast. A general release cannot be stretched to cover those uses. The team needs a new, specific release that names public digital marketing, paid social advertising, the donation page, and broadcast or TV use. If Maria declines, do not use her identifiable interview; use staff voices or anonymous b-roll instead, and do not imply her story through editing.
The child’s face is a separate issue. A minor cannot consent, so a guardian release is required for identifiable use. If that is not available before the deadline, blur the face or reframe the shot. The music track is also unresolved: a track found online is not licensed for ads or broadcast. Replace it with a cleared library track or commissioned music, and keep the license record.
The TV station may require broadcast rights and a higher-resolution master. The paid ad must also meet Meta’s ad policies. Document every permission before publishing. The ethical test is not whether the team can argue the old release is close enough; it is whether Maria and the child’s guardian understood and agreed to these specific uses.
2. Given the available footage and ten editor hours, what production decisions most improve the cut?
Read the worked answer
Start with delivery specs, because they determine the edit. Make a 16:9 master for the donation page and TV, then crop a 1:1 or 9:16 version for Meta with safe zones for captions and UI. Conform the 60 fps vertical footage to a 30 fps timeline to avoid stutter and mixed-motion look; do not upscale the 1080 horizontal footage beyond its useful limit.
Spend the limited hours in this order:
- Audio repair. Remove the refrigerator hum with a noise-reduction pass, then EQ and compress. If intelligibility is still poor, record a clean voiceover from Maria or a staff narrator rather than forcing bad sync audio.
- Exposure and color. The backlit window will silhouette the speaker. Pull down highlights, lift shadows, and use a simple grade to match the two phones.
- Captions. Burn in open captions for social and supply an SRT for the donation page and TV. Captions are accessibility, not decoration, and they also help silent viewing.
- Structure. Open with a concrete need in the first five seconds, then Maria’s story, then the ask. Keep the child shot only if cleared; otherwise use food-line b-roll without faces.
- Sound and music. Use a cleared track, duck it under speech, and normalize to a consistent loudness.
Do not spend hours on complex motion graphics. The highest-risk failures are inaudible speech, missing captions, and uncleared rights, not lack of polish.
3. The director wants a strong “Donate now” ending, but the page only accepts one-time gifts. What should guide the call to action and the edit?
Read the worked answer
The call to action must match what the donor can actually do. A generic “Donate now” is acceptable if the landing page clearly offers one-time giving, but the video should not imply monthly giving, matching, or a deadline that the page cannot support. If the director wants a recurring-gift message, the page needs recurring functionality first; otherwise the ad will drive clicks that cannot convert as promised.
Edit the ending around a single action: “Give once today” or “Fund a week of groceries,” with a short URL and a visual of the donation page. Avoid stacking multiple asks such as volunteer, donate, and follow in the last five seconds. For the TV version, use a spoken and on-screen URL rather than a QR code alone, since broadcast viewers may not be able to scan.
Also consider the donor’s information needs: what the gift funds, whether it is tax-deductible, and how the donation is processed. These should be on the landing page, not crowded into the video. The ethical risk is overpromising impact or urgency. The practical risk is a high-emotion ad that produces clicks but no completed gifts. Test the ending with five staff or volunteers before final export.