The Door-to-Door Sewing Machine Offer
A family in a small town wants to buy a sewing machine so that the mother can take tailoring work at home. Their savings are ₹12,000. A door-to-door agent offers a machine for ₹11,500 with a 'special discount' if they pay cash and do not ask for a bill. He also offers a 12-month instalment plan: ₹1,150 per month, with the first payment today. He shows a label that says 'ISO' and claims it is 'the same as ISI'. A local shop sells a similar machine for ₹12,400, gives a printed bill, a two-year warranty, a free demonstration at home, and a contact number for repairs. The family's monthly income is about ₹18,000, and they already pay ₹2,500 as rent. The mother likes the agent's offer because the monthly payment seems small.
1. Calculate the real cost of the instalment offer and compare it with the local shop price. What would you advise?
Read the worked answer
The instalment plan costs 12 × ₹1,150 = ₹13,800. The cash price quoted by the agent is ₹11,500, so the extra cost of buying on instalments is ₹13,800 − ₹11,500 = ₹2,300. On a loan of about ₹11,500, that is roughly 20% of the price over one year, which is a high cost of credit. The local shop price is ₹12,400 with a bill and a two-year warranty. Even the local shop is cheaper than the instalment total: ₹13,800 − ₹12,400 = ₹1,400 less. The instalment plan also has no bill and no written warranty, so the family has no proof of purchase. My advice is not to accept the door-to-door offer. If they can pay cash, the local shop is the safer choice because of the bill, warranty, demonstration, and repair contact. If they cannot pay the full amount, they should save for a few months or buy from a shop that offers a written instalment agreement with the total cost stated.
2. The agent says 'ISO is the same as ISI'. Explain why this claim should not be accepted, and what the family should check before buying.
Read the worked answer
The claim is misleading. ISI is a certification mark used under the Bureau of Indian Standards system for products covered by Indian Standards. ISO is an international standards organisation; an 'ISO' label by itself does not show that a particular sewing machine has been tested and certified for safety and quality in India. The family should look for a genuine certification mark on the product or its packaging, read the model number, and ask for the printed warranty and instruction manual. They should check whether the machine runs smoothly, whether spare parts are available locally, and whether the shop will provide a demonstration. They should insist on a bill with the date, model, serial number, price, and warranty terms. A label alone is not a substitute for these checks.
3. What consumer rights and remedies are relevant if the machine breaks down and the seller refuses to help?
Read the worked answer
The family has the right to safety, the right to be informed, the right to choose, and the right to redress. A printed bill and warranty card are the evidence. If the seller refuses to honour the warranty, the family can first make a written complaint to the shop, keeping a copy. If that fails, they can approach the district Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission or the national consumer helpline, depending on the value of the claim. They should keep the machine, the bill, the warranty card, and any messages or receipts. If they bought without a bill, their position is much weaker, which is why the bill matters. The family should not allow the machine to be taken away for repair without a written receipt. The remedy could be repair, replacement, or refund, depending on the defect and the warranty terms.