Thirteen marks in twenty-two minutes: choosing between two letters and an essay
The composition section offers three choices: (a) a letter to a friend describing a school excursion (5 marks, about 100 words); (b) an application to the headmaster for a bonafide certificate (5 marks, about 80 words); (c) an essay on 'ಪರಿಸರ ಸಂರಕ್ಷಣೆ' (8 marks, about 150 words). Sana has 22 minutes and needs 11 of these 13 marks to reach her target; she has already abandoned two 1-mark items elsewhere on the paper. She writes about 14 words a minute in Kannada but plans slowly. She knows the formal-letter frame cold. She also has a memorised 35-word essay opening that she likes to use whatever the topic, and she is tempted to attempt all three choices 'for safety'. She has no watch and is relying on the wall clock at the back of the hall.
1. Which choices should Sana attempt, and how should the 22 minutes be allocated? Show the arithmetic rather than the instinct.
Read the worked answer
Capacity check: 22 minutes × 14 words a minute ≈ 300 words of raw writing. Slow planning and format-setting for two pieces removes roughly 3–4 minutes, leaving about 240–250 words of usable text.
Option arithmetic:
- (a) + (b) = 180 words but only 10 marks - below her required 11. Excluded.
- (b) + (c) = 80 + 150 = 230 words, 13 marks - fits inside capacity with a small margin.
- (a) + (c) = 100 + 150 = 250 words, 13 marks - sits exactly at capacity, no slack, and the excursion letter needs invented detail, which is the slowest kind of planning.
Decision: attempt (b) and (c) only.
Allocation: application 8 minutes (1 minute setting the frame, 7 minutes writing ≈ 95 words, comfortably over 80); essay 12 minutes (2 minutes planning, 10 minutes writing ≈ 140 words, accept a small shortfall); 2 minutes to re-check format elements.
On the abandoned 1-mark items: only if she can answer each from memory in under 20 seconds. Otherwise they cost the essay's planning time and endanger 13 marks for 2.
2. List the format elements the application must carry, and identify the ones candidates most often lose marks on.
Read the worked answer
Elements to include, in order:
- Sender's address at the top left.
- Date below it.
- Receiver's designation and institution - ಮುಖ್ಯೋಪಾಧ್ಯಾಯರು, with the school name.
- Salutation: 'ಮಾನ್ಯ ಮುಖ್ಯೋಪಾಧ್ಯಾಯರೇ,'
- Subject line: 'ವಿಷಯ: ಪ್ರವೇಶ ಪ್ರಮಾಣಪತ್ರ ಕೋರುವ ಬಗ್ಗೆ' (requesting a bonafide certificate).
- Body: purpose, one supporting detail (class, roll number, the reason the certificate is needed), then a clear request sentence.
- Sign-off: 'ತಮ್ಮ ವಿಧೇಯ ವಿದ್ಯಾರ್ಥಿನಿ' plus name and class.
Most common losses:
- Omitting the date or the subject line - cheap marks gone in one line.
- Using a friend's salutation ('ಆತ್ಮೀಯ ಗೆಳೆಯನೇ') in a formal letter, or a nickname in the sign-off.
- No explicit request sentence - the letter describes the problem but never asks for the certificate.
- Writing the body as an essay and running past 80 words while the frame is incomplete.
Format marks are the most predictable marks in the paper; they should never be traded for extra sentences of content.
3. Her memorised essay opening runs to 35 words and is general. How should she adapt it to protect both marks and word count?
Read the worked answer
Cut it to one specific sentence.
The arithmetic: 35 words out of a 150-word essay is nearly a quarter of the budget spent before any content point is made. In a 12-minute essay slot it also consumes roughly 2.5 minutes.
What to do instead:
- Open with one concrete, local detail - a named lake, a number, a street, a season - instead of a general statement about the environment. Specificity is what content marks reward.
- Budget the rest: ~20 words introduction, ~100 words body with two or three concrete points (segregating waste at home, planting in the school compound, stopping water waste), ~25 words conclusion with an appeal.
- Use her stored phrase only if it actually answers 'ಪರಿಸರ ಸಂರಕ್ಷಣೆ'. A memorised opening that fits any topic usually fits none, and irrelevant material invites deduction rather than credit.
Reasoning: the temptation is to treat the memorised opening as insurance. In practice it is the most expensive 35 words on the page - they earn nothing, they push her over the limit, and they buy no time because she still has to think of the content that follows.