Renewal Season With an Accommodation Request and Service Complaints
Maple Ridge is a 300-unit community at 93% occupancy. In the next 90 days, 180 leases expire. Current average rent is $1,350; market comparables support $1,425, and ownership wants an 8% increase on renewals. Last year's renewal acceptance was 55%. Resident surveys rank parking enforcement, after-hours noise, and work-order speed as the top problems, and the community's online rating is 3.6. A 72-year-old resident who has lived there for 11 years has asked to transfer from a second-floor to a first-floor unit because of arthritis; no first-floor unit is expected to be available for four months. Turn cost is $2,800, average vacancy loss is 21 days, and the manager has authority to vary renewal increases by up to 2 percentage points.
1. Segment the 180 expiring leases and design a renewal strategy. How should the manager use the 2-point flexibility?
Read the worked answer
Segment by tenure, payment history, unit type, rent-to-market gap, and complaint history. Long-tenure residents with good payment and unresolved service issues are the highest retention risk; fix their issues before sending an 8% offer. For residents already at or near market, use the full 8% or the top of the allowed range; for long-tenure residents with a large gap to market and high turnover risk, use the 2-point flexibility to offer 6% and explain the market. Avoid a uniform letter. Calculate the breakeven: $108 per month times 12 is $1,296 per year; a turn costs about $2,800 plus 21 days of vacancy (about $945), or $3,745. It takes about 35 months of the increase to recover one avoidable turn. That justifies conceding 2 points (about $27 per month) to keep a good resident. Send offers 90 days out and follow with a personal call.
2. How should the manager respond to the transfer request while maintaining retention and fair housing compliance?
Read the worked answer
Treat the transfer as a possible reasonable accommodation. Acknowledge the request in writing, ask what specific accommodation is needed, and request supporting documentation only if the disability or need is not obvious. Do not promise a unit that is not available. Explore interim options: priority on the first-floor waitlist, a temporary first-floor unit if one exists, assigned parking closer to the building, or a modified transfer date. Keep the resident in her current unit and avoid retaliation. Apply the same process consistently to all accommodation requests, keep medical information confidential, and document dates and decisions. From a retention standpoint, offer a renewal at the low end of the range and explain the transfer timeline; losing an 11-year resident over a temporary delay is more costly than a 2-point rent concession.
3. Calculate the financial case for spending $15,000 on parking enforcement, noise monitoring, and a work-order coordinator. What metrics would determine whether it worked?
Read the worked answer
Financial case: 180 renewals; moving acceptance from 55% to 65% avoids about 18 turns. At $3,745 per turn (turn cost plus vacancy), avoided cost is about $67,410, far above $15,000, before counting the rent increases retained. But the estimate is only valid if the improvements actually prevent non-renewals rather than delay them. Track renewal acceptance by segment, turnover rate, work-order cycle time, noise complaints, parking violations, online rating, and resident satisfaction before and after. Compare the $15,000 to the cost of the same number of turns; if the pilot only improves satisfaction but not renewal, reallocate. Spend in phases: parking enforcement and work-order coordinator first, noise monitoring second, with a 90-day review.