Four Minutes of Pasta Sauce and a Ten-Day Deadline
Your insured is a regional grocery chain. A 62-year-old customer slipped on a spilled jar of pasta sauce in aisle 7 and fell, injuring her back. Store video shows the spill had been down four minutes and that the claimant was walking while looking at her phone when she fell. Her providers billed $84,000, of which $31,000 was already adjusted away by her health plan. She claims $18,000 in lost wages as a self-employed bookkeeper. Her surgeon recommends a two-level fusion with an estimated $95,000 cost and two years of projected future care. Venue is a plaintiff-friendly county. Her attorney sends a $500,000 policy-limit demand with a 10-day deadline, attaching only an emergency room bill and a one-page doctor's note.
1. Build a defensible evaluation range for this claim and show the arithmetic.
Read the worked answer
Liability - severe for the insured. A four-minute puddle defeats any argument that the store lacked constructive notice; most jurisdictions treat a few minutes as enough for a jury. The claimant's phone use supports comparative fault, realistically 15–25% under New York's pure comparative negligence rule.
Past medical. Billed $84,000, but the health plan wrote off $31,000. Reasonable value is roughly $55,000–$65,000; expect the defense to argue the write-down under the collateral source rule.
Past wages. $18,000 claimed, unsupported by tax returns. As a self-employed bookkeeper she must produce Schedule C and client logs. Budget $8,000–$14,000 after haircut.
Future medical. $95,000 surgery plus two years of care, discounted to present value and reduced by the probability the surgery occurs: $80,000–$120,000.
Pain and suffering. A fusion in a 62-year-old with a documented disc injury: $150,000–$300,000.
Verdict range: roughly $350,000–$520,000. At 20% comparative fault: $280,000–$415,000. Set a $400,000 reserve and seek authority to open at $150,000 with a ceiling near $275,000.
2. How do you respond to the policy-limits demand before the deadline expires?
Read the worked answer
The 10-day deadline creates no legal obligation to pay, but ignoring it invites an excess/bad-faith claim - the file must show a good-faith evaluation.
Send a written response before day ten that:
- Acknowledges the demand and states the policy limit.
- Explains that a policy-limits evaluation cannot be made on an ER bill and a one-page note.
- Requests specifically: all treating records and imaging, the operative recommendation with CPT codes, bills for all providers, Schedule C and business records supporting the wage claim, evidence of any prior back treatment, lien and Medicare status, and a signed authorization.
- Reserves all rights, including the right to contest damages and comparative fault.
- Makes a good-faith opening offer or a firm statement that an offer will follow within a stated number of days after records arrive.
If records arrive and the exposure is genuinely near or above limits, paying the limit is the cheaper course. If not, a documented counteroffer protects the insurer. Never let the deadline pass with silence in the file.
3. What lien and collateral-source issues must be resolved before any release is signed?
Read the worked answer
Medicare. Run the claimant through the Section 111 query process to establish Medicare status. If she is a beneficiary, obtain a final demand letter from the Medicare Secondary Payer contractor before disbursing, and address future medicals (the surgery) either by a Medicare Set-Aside or by confirming the settlement excludes future Medicare-covered care.
Medicare Advantage / Part D. These plans have private causes of action independent of traditional Medicare and must be separately resolved.
Medicaid. Recoverable at the Medicaid rate, which is typically a fraction of billed charges; obtain the lien amount in writing.
Health plan and collateral source. Under CPLR 4545 the defense may seek a hearing to reduce an award by the amount of the write-off; factor that into negotiation rather than assuming the full $84,000 is recoverable.
Release language. Include a hold-harmless and indemnity from the claimant for all liens, condition the check on written lien resolutions, and consider naming the plans as payees. A release that ignores a Medicare Advantage plan is not a final release.