Disclosure of Childhood Asthma and Pre-Run Inhaler Use
An 18-year-old candidate has passed the initial academic and physical screening and is filling the medical form before interview. He had asthma until age 10, has had no attack for 7 years, but keeps a salbutamol inhaler and uses it before 1.6 km runs just in case. He also sprained his ankle 5 weeks ago; it is now pain-free with no swelling, but he did not complete rehabilitation. The form asks: Any history of asthma? and Current medicines. He fears that ticking yes will end his selection, so he considers leaving both blank. In the interview, the officer asks whether he has any medical condition or medication. The candidate must decide what to disclose, how to phrase it, what records to bring, and how to answer if asked whether the inhaler is necessary.
1. Should he disclose the childhood asthma and inhaler use? Give the ethical and practical reasoning.
Read the worked answer
Yes. The form is a declaration, and integrity is a selection criterion, not a formality. Leaving it blank is a false declaration and can end his candidacy more surely than the condition itself. Practically, the medical officer needs the history to assess risk during strenuous training. Childhood asthma that has been quiet for 7 years may be minor, but current inhaler use is still a current medicine and must be declared even if it is only precautionary. The candidate should not decide fitness himself; the medical officer decides with records. Disclosure also protects him if breathing problems occur later, because the history is already known.
2. Draft a concise interview response and list the documents he should bring.
Read the worked answer
Suggested response: I had asthma until about age 10 and have had no attacks or hospital visits for 7 years. I have a salbutamol inhaler prescribed for exercise and use it before runs as a precaution, not because of daily symptoms. Here is my prescription and a doctor’s note. I also sprained my ankle 5 weeks ago; it is pain-free now with no swelling, and I can provide the treatment record. Documents: prescription or inhaler box, GP or specialist letter covering asthma history and current exercise capacity, peak-flow record if available, and ankle rehabilitation or clinic note. He should answer briefly, honestly and without volunteering unrelated excuses.
3. What should he do if the medical officer says the inhaler makes him temporarily unfit pending review?
Read the worked answer
He should accept the decision, ask exactly what review is required, and provide the requested records rather than argue or conceal. He can ask whether the review needs a specialist letter, a supervised exercise test, or a repeat medical, and he should follow that process. Meanwhile he should maintain fitness safely and not train around a restriction. If the decision is final for this attempt, he should seek the documented appeal or reapplication route. Hiding the inhaler after being questioned would be a integrity and safety failure and could lead to disqualification.