Harborline Coffee Roasters: A Grocery Chain Deal with Strings
Harborline Coffee Roasters sells 60% of its 12-ounce bags wholesale to 42 independent grocers and cafés at $6.60 per bag and 40% direct-to-consumer online at $15.50 plus a $4.80 shipping charge that Harborline subsidizes. Landed product and packaging cost is $4.15 per bag; wholesale freight averages $0.55 per bag, and DTC payment processing is 3% of the order. A 28-store regional grocery chain has offered to carry the line in all stores, forecasting 1,800 bags per month. Its terms: $18,000 slotting fee, a 20% off-invoice promotional allowance on first-year volume, 45-day payment terms, and a suggested retail price of $11.99. Harborline's existing café accounts sell brewed coffee at $3.75–$4.25 per cup and bags at $14.99, and two have already complained about seeing the brand discounted online. The roaster has 1,100 pounds of weekly capacity and is running at 82% utilization. The owner likes the volume but worries about margin, channel conflict, and cash.
1. Calculate Harborline's per-bag contribution for the chain deal, including amortized slotting. Should Harborline accept the chain's terms as proposed? Recommend specific counterterms.
Read the worked answer
Baseline wholesale contribution is $6.60 − $4.15 − $0.55 = $1.90 per bag, a 28.8% margin. With a 20% allowance applied to all first-year volume, net price is $5.28, so contribution falls to $5.28 − $4.70 = $0.58 per bag. At 1,800 bags per month, annual contribution is $0.58 × 1,800 × 12 = $12,528. Slotting of $18,000 amortized over 12 months is $1,500 per month, or $0.83 per bag, which turns the deal negative: $12,528 − $18,000 = −$5,472 in year one. Break-even volume is $1,500 / $0.58 = 2,586 bags per month, far above the forecast. The 45-day terms also tie up cash. Do not accept as proposed. Counter with slotting of $6,000 or less, the 20% allowance limited to a 90-day launch window or to 30% of volume, and 30-day terms. If the chain insists on full slotting, require a written commitment to at least 2,600 bags per month or a co-op marketing contribution. Walk away if the chain will not share the launch risk.
2. Assess the channel-conflict risk between the chain, the 42 independents, and DTC. Recommend a channel and pricing policy, including the legal limits of a MAP policy.
Read the worked answer
DTC contribution is $15.50 − $4.15 − $4.80 − $0.47 = $6.08 per bag, more than ten times the chain deal's $0.58. Harborline should not let the chain cannibalize DTC or café accounts. At $11.99 retail, the chain undercuts the cafés' $14.99 bag price and sits close to the DTC price before shipping, so price-sensitive customers will shift and cafés may delist the brand. Differentiate the package: the chain gets a 10-ounce bag or an exclusive blend; cafés keep the 12-ounce and foodservice formats. Adopt a unilateral minimum advertised price policy at $12.99 for the 12-ounce bag, applied uniformly and reviewed by counsel. A unilateral MAP policy is generally lawful, but negotiating resale prices with individual retailers can create antitrust exposure, and state rules vary. Keep DTC differentiated with subscriptions and bundles so it is not a direct price comparison. Give the 42 independents advance notice and a protected margin or promotional calendar before the chain launches, not after.
3. Calculate the volume increase required to make the 20% allowance contribution-neutral. What does the result imply for how Harborline should structure trade promotions?
Read the worked answer
Baseline contribution is $1.90 per bag; during the allowance it is $0.58. To hold total contribution constant on a base of 1,000 bags, Harborline needs 1,000 × $1.90 / $0.58 = 3,276 bags, a 228% increase. Trade promotions rarely produce that unless they are paired with display and feature advertising. The incremental break-even is even more demanding: if the chain would sell 1,800 bags per month anyway, applying the 20% allowance to all of them costs $1.32 × 1,800 = $2,376 per month, which requires 4,097 incremental bags at $0.58 to recover-implausible. Structure promotions as short, scan-based events with a performance commitment: for example, 20% off for eight weeks tied to feature and display, with a sell-through report and a cap on total allowance dollars. Fund a first-order discount instead of a full-year allowance, and calculate the break-even lift before approving any promotion. A promotion that is not contribution-neutral at realistic lift is a price cut with extra paperwork.