Expired permit, added floor and pre-sold flats in Yerevan
A developer in Yerevan holds a construction permit for a six-storey residential building with one underground parking level on a 0.18 ha lot. The permit was issued in March 2021 for three years. In June 2024, while the permit was still valid, the company cast a seventh floor and changed the street facade from stone veneer to aluminium panels without notifying the municipality. The permit expired in March 2024, but finishing works continued until August 2024, when an inspector issued a stop-work order. Forty-two apartments have been pre-sold. A neighbouring owner complains that the added floor increases shadowing and that the parking entrance encroaches on a 3 m setback. The company asks whether it can legalise the building as built and continue sales.
1. Identify the violations and explain which can be regularised and which cannot under Armenian urban development legislation. Give the reasoning, not just a list.
Read the worked answer
The permit is a time-bound authorisation. Work executed after March 2024 falls outside it and is unauthorised construction even though the earlier structure was lawful. The seventh floor is a different problem from mere expiry: it departs from the approved design and may breach height, floor-area ratio, insolation and seismic requirements. Under Armenian urban development law, an unauthorised building does not become lawful merely by paying a fine. Regularisation requires a new building permit, an expert conclusion that the as-built structure complies with technical regulations, and, where town-planning rules are affected, a public hearing. If the floor creates a normative violation such as a setback, height or insolation breach, or reduces seismic safety, the permissible remedy is removal of the offending part, not a fine. The facade change may be approvable as a design amendment if it does not affect structural, fire or thermal performance. The parking entrance encroaching on the 3 m setback is a separate planning breach and may require relocation or demolition. Sales before an occupancy certificate expose the developer to invalidity and refund claims.
2. Set out a sequenced action plan for the developer covering the municipality, expert review and buyers.
Read the worked answer
First, keep the stop-work order in force, secure the site and commission an as-built survey. Second, carry out a legal audit of the permit, approved design and all changes. Third, appoint an independent expert examination covering seismic safety, fire safety, insolation and the setback encroachment. Fourth, decide the planning route: apply for a new permit and amended design for the remaining works only if the as-built structure can comply; otherwise propose removal of the seventh floor and relocation of the parking entrance. Fifth, hold the required public hearing and pay administrative penalties, which do not substitute for permits. Sixth, obtain the commissioning act before any handover or registration. For buyers, disclose the enforcement status, stop accepting new deposits, offer rescission or amended contracts with an escrow mechanism, and do not promise registration dates that depend on an unfavourable expert conclusion. If demolition is required, negotiate compensation before sales resume.